Blog

User Feedback: The Definitive Guide for Product Managers

SaaS Product Management
Aug 3, 2023
User Feedback: The Definitive Guide for Product Managers

Because without real input, you’re just building features in the dark.

Imagine launching a new feature you’ve spent two sprints refining. Your team’s proud. Design feels polished. QA found zero bugs. You even got a little applause on Slack.

Then… nothing.
Engagement flatlines.
A few users click in, then bounce out.
Support logs a vague complaint: “Someone said it was confusing.”

You didn’t need vanity metrics.
You needed real feedback.

But here’s the thing most product managers already know—and still struggle with:

Getting feedback that’s useful, honest, and timely is harder than it looks.

It’s not just about surveys. Or asking users what they think. Or adding a “Give feedback” button and calling it a day.
It’s about getting the right information, at the right moment, from the right users—and doing something with it.

Let’s dig into how product managers can actually gather user feedback in a way that fuels smart product decisions (and doesn't clog your backlog with weird one-off requests from Greg in accounting).

What kind of feedback do you really need?

First: let’s kill the vague idea of “getting feedback” as a blanket strategy. Different stages of product development call for very different kinds of input.

Think of feedback like fuel—some powers research, some powers prioritization, some powers iteration.

Here’s how to break it down:

Goal

Feedback You Need

Early-stage idea validation

Qualitative feedback from target personas (pain points, current hacks)

Pre-launch testing

Usability feedback, friction points, onboarding experience

Post-launch measurement

Feature adoption data + open-ended commentary

Retention optimization

Insights on what's driving long-term use—or churn

Roadmap planning

Strategic feedback on gaps, unmet needs, and “jobs to be done”

Instead of collecting all the feedback, focus on the right questions for the right moment. That’s how you turn scattered opinions into insights you can ship with.

Where to find feedback (hint: it's not just your NPS score)

If your only feedback loop is an NPS survey every six months, you’re missing 90% of what your users are trying to tell you.

Here are the actual places user feedback hides:

1. Support tickets and live chat transcripts

These are goldmines of honest user pain. Every time someone contacts support, it’s a chance to learn what broke, confused, or disappointed them. But don’t just read the complaints—look for the questions they keep asking.

Flag repeat themes. Tag the friction points. These are roadmap clues. If your business offers a coworking space app, you can also track issues related to space availability, booking conflicts, or user interface concerns to better streamline your app's functionality.

2. Sales and success teams

Your customer-facing teams are having real conversations every day. They’re hearing objections, concerns, and recurring “if only you could…” moments.

Build a habit of listening in. Sit in on a few calls. Ask them, “What keeps coming up lately?”

3. User interviews

Old-school, yes. But nothing beats a one-on-one conversation where you just listen. Let them talk. Let them rant. Ask dumb questions.

The nuance you get from hearing how someone describes a problem? That’s where real understanding lives.

Tip: you don’t need to talk to 100 people. Ten well-chosen users from different segments can reveal themes that no survey ever will.

4. In-app microfeedback

Context matters. Ask the right question at the right moment inside your product. Like:

  • After onboarding: “Was anything unclear while getting started?”

  • After trying a feature: “Did this do what you expected?”

  • After canceling: “What made you leave today?”

These light, low-friction touchpoints often get more useful responses than formal surveys.

5. Product usage data

Behavior is feedback. If users are skipping a feature entirely, that’s telling. If they drop off after onboarding step two, you’ve got your signal.

Combine quantitative (clicks, flows, bounce) with qualitative (what they say) to see the full picture.

How to ask better questions (and stop collecting garbage data)

You know what gets you bad feedback?

Bad questions.

Things like:

  • “What do you think about the new dashboard?” (Too broad)

  • “Would you use this feature?” (Everyone says yes, few mean it)

  • “What should we build next?” (Don’t do this to yourself)

Better questions dig into behavior, context, and motivation.
Here are a few to steal:

  • “Tell me about the last time you tried to do X—what worked and what didn’t?”

  • “What’s the hardest part of your workflow right now?”

  • “If you could wave a magic wand and change one thing, what would it be?”

  • “What do you still use Excel for, even though you’re using our product?”

And when someone makes a specific request? Always ask:

“What problem are you trying to solve with that?”

Because the why matters more than the feature idea itself.

What to do with all this feedback (aka: don’t just dump it in Notion)

Feedback without a system is just noise.

Here’s how to make it useful:

1. Centralize it

Pick one place—Airtable, Coda, Productboard, Trello, doesn’t matter. Just make it searchable, taggable, and easy for your team to access.

2. Tag it by theme

Don’t just log comments. Tag them by type:

  • Onboarding friction

  • Feature confusion

  • Integration requests

  • Missing functionality

  • UX bugs

  • Language/terminology issues

Patterns emerge fast when your data is structured.

3. Quantify it where possible

If 4 out of 10 onboarding users mention the same confusing step? You’ve got a measurable signal. If 2 out of 500 want a super niche feature? Maybe not a priority.

Numbers give context. Use them.

This is why it’s important to use good feature request software (or product management software / workflow management tools) that lets you quantify and prioritize feature requests as they come in.

Some popular examples include Featurebase, Feedbear, Canny, and others.

4. Loop it into roadmap conversations

Every sprint planning or roadmap review should include:

“What’s the most common feedback we’ve seen in the last 2 weeks?”

You’re not a feature request machine. But feedback should always be part of the product conversation during your SaaS app development.

The feedback that looks good but leads you astray

Let’s talk about misleading feedback. Because not all of it is helpful—even when it’s positive.

Watch out for:

🧼 The polite praise trap

“Looks great!” is not useful. “This is amazing!” doesn’t tell you why.
People often default to being nice. That’s not insight.

Ask: What exactly did you like? What part felt especially helpful?

🧙 The feature wishlist syndrome

Users suggest what they think they want, not what they need.
“Add AI” is not a problem statement. It’s a trend chasing a use case.

Dig into: What’s the job they’re trying to do? What’s missing now?

🥱 The vocal minority effect

Just because one user emailed you 12 times doesn’t mean they represent the majority.
Weight feedback based on volume, recency, and relevance—not volume of voice.

Following up: the part most teams forget

Want to earn loyalty? Follow up.

Tell people what happened with the feedback they gave—even if you didn’t implement it.

Example:

“Thanks for sharing that suggestion about simplifying reports. We’re not tackling that in this sprint, but we’ve logged it and added your use case—appreciate the context.”

And if you do build something based on user input?

Shout them out. Show them. Invite them to try the beta.
Turn feedback into community—and your users become your biggest advocates.

Final thoughts: feedback isn’t a checkbox—it’s your product engine

If you’re guessing what to build next, you’ve already lost ground.
If you’re only reacting to complaints, you’re too late.
And if your “user insights” are locked in a dusty spreadsheet, you’re not listening—you’re archiving.

The best product managers know that user feedback isn’t about collecting more opinions. It’s about asking better questions, listening at the right time, and turning raw input into sharp decisions.

You don’t need 10,000 responses.
You need a dozen good ones—aligned, honest, and specific.

So step back. Ask smarter. Listen deeper.
And build the product with your users, not just for them.

Good decisions start with actionable insights.

Build your first embedded data product now. Talk to our product experts for a guided demo or get your hands dirty with a free 10-day trial.

Dashboard